Arcade Fire Brian Wilson Britney Spears Danger Mouse Franz Ferdinand From The Archives Green Day Jay-Z Kanye West Loretta Lynn M.I.A. Modest Mouse Movies and Games Music Pazz & Jop Robert Christgau The Culture The Streets U2 Usher Yeah Yeah Yeahs

2004 Pazz & Jop: Freedom for Every-Which-Where!

2004 Pazz & Jop: Freedom for Every-Which-Where!

Whine about Lil Jon and Ashlee Simpson if you’d like. There was nonetheless loads of excellent news in widespread music this yr, and it’s everywhere in the 31st or 32nd Pazz & Jop Critics’ Ballot, our largest ever hey hey hey. Any album listing headed by The School Dropout, through which younger Kanye West proved as deft and shocking a recalibrator of African American crossover as younger Barack Obama, and SMiLE, through which acid casualty Brian Wilson excavated the identical pivotal decade that tripped up veteran John Kerry, has its past-and-future straight. Any Prime 10 that boasts three alt-minded rock bands who’ve satisfied the RIAA to blingify their CDs is preventing the great battle. And if the Prime 10 additionally reveals would-be optimists overrating good intentions and pretending small victories are huge ones, nicely, that was 2004 for you. The Democrats gained management of the Colorado legislature November 2. Hey hey hey.

So proper, it’s good that dapper Franz Ferdinand invaded and bizarre younger Modest Mouse flowered into goofy older Mickey Mouse — good too, type of, that every revived the venture-capital mannequin through which main labels wager seed cash on bands who’re in it for the music, sort of. Congrats to the not-for-profit Gray Album, Hazard Mouse’s unlawful mash-up of Jay-Z (company honcho throws self on open market) and the Beatles (company keepers brandish attorneys). Thank Jack White for refurbishing Loretta Lynn and U2 for refurbishing war-is-over-if-you-want-it. The Streets’ Mike Skinner warmed up for his Booker Prize, and with enter from some Texan carpetbaggers, our nonfascist neighbor to the north generated an alt-rock sleeper cell worthy of its overwrought raves. And who can fault Inexperienced Day, whose “punk opera” not solely revived their gross sales however acquired nominated for an album Grammy whereas calling People the idiots they’re?

All however one among these are admirable data. However I want I might swear they belong in the identical paragraph with The School Dropout and SMiLE. Perhaps the Arcade Hearth’s Funeral, whose unabashed loveliness and sophisticated tone might portend one thing wider ranging, or simply grander. However the U2 is the genial entrance job any reality-based evaluation would predict, the Franz Ferdinand and Modest Mouse are light-weight on function with out attaining buoyancy, and I’m not the primary listener to reluctantly conclude that A Grand Don’t Come for Free, Van Lear Rose, and The Gray Album learn higher than they sound. After which there’s American Fool. In a yr when pop musicians politicized with unprecedented unanimity —  Nashville alone pro-Bush, many actively opposing the reactionaries and/or getting out the vote, and just a few rappers sidestepping Kerry on lefter-than-thou grounds — American Fool was the only Prime 10 album to take a protesty tack, and acquired a lot love for it. However to my ears it founders on sodden songcraft — by no means thoughts Dookie, attempt the tunes on 2000’s uncared for (and no much less acutely aware) Warning — and half-congealed themes. Past some mild name-calling (sharpest on the Japan-only B aspect “Governator”), the signature “Don’t need to be an American fool” was so far as its politics went, as a result of American Fool is in substance an anti-political report. Finally, it’s about punk’s incapability to vary something, even Billie Joe. That uninteresting buildup you hear is the acquainted sound of confusion taking itself critically.

I impute this message of helplessness to the murals, not its creator, who did additionally put a track on a Rock Towards Bush comp. However the place I’d quite get my artwork is Rock Towards Bush itself — or NOFX’s 2003 The Struggle on Errorism, not precisely Linton Kwesi Johnson however smarter than Inexperienced Day, even on “Idiots Are Taking Over.” Such smarts show extremely intermittent on our 2004 lists. They present up in Rilo Kiley’s CEO-targeting “It’s a Hit” and Tom Waits’s war-torn “Hoist That Rag” and Morrissey’s waspish “America Is Not the World,” in Nellie McKay’s wisecracks and the Drive-By Truckers’ worldview, in rumblings from U2 and TV on the Radio, within the hardcore rabble-rousing of Eminem’s “Mosh” and the vernacular conspiracy mongering of Jadakiss’s “Why?” And that’s about it. Odd, no? This was definitely the primary presidential election in Pazz & Jop historical past to dominate artists’ and voters’ mindsets. But the election’s points and personalities remained all however unaddressed by the music the ballot honored. My guess is that this disconnect succumbs to the hoary fallacy — belied alone listing by Todd Snider, Jon Langford, Andre Tanker, Public Enemy and Moby — that “artwork” precludes “propaganda.” However for functions of argument let me posit as an alternative that it was deep-structural. All these passionate anti-Bushies stored on musicking as typical as a result of they sensed that nothing lower than the liberty to make and listen to the valuable stuff was at stake.

In different phrases, we weren’t being “liberals,” striving to guard the unlucky right here and abroad. We have been appearing out of uncooked self-interest. Not simply because believable situations involving terrorist assault (keep in mind terrorist assault?) might shortly rework our democracy right into a bold-faced showpiece of postmodern fascism. Not simply because some commerce or foreign money wrinkle too boring to enter might impoverish us all. However as a result of constitutional democracy, as conceived by those that now management its mechanisms, is being retooled to render your way of life and mine fiscally intolerable. By no means thoughts Social Safety, the place “reform” would kick in slowly, sandbagging the younger individuals now being advised that boomers need to steal their payroll taxes. There’s a quicker option to destroy the security internet, soaking states the place rudiments of presidency for the individuals survive — specifically, to abolish the federal tax deduction for state and native taxes within the identify of balancing a finances squandered on the wealthy and Iraq, thus forcing blue states to slash human providers and decreasing their residents’ discretionary revenue. It’s sufficient to tempt your Democratic consultant so as to add a buck in VAT to the worth of each CD.

Math being for poobahs and Harvard M.B.A.’s, I apologize for burdening you with these apparently nonmusical abstractions. However Bush’s willpower to compel all of us to compete Darwinistically for our semblance of consolation — to transform each American right into a mini-capitalist or a serf — has musical penalties. The related objectives, on this context, are the privatization of progress and the curtailment of leisure by pressured attrition. By withdrawing from the human providers sector, the federal government will dare do-gooders to place their cash the place their rhetoric is. And naturally, each improve in work hours and discount in discretionary revenue starves the music and movie industries — which at their crassest stay stubbornly liberal — and shrinks the humanities’ materials base in academia, bohemia, and the serving to professions. Collateral injury is a specialty of those robbers with fountain pens.

In such dire circumstances, happening about rock criticism and its discontents feels frivolous. Slogging by way of feedback that included in depth alternatives from blogs I by no means learn, I used to be typically irritated by the insularity of all of it. Franz Ferdinand and Loretta Lynn, Usher and Devendra Banhart, Morrissey and Elliott Smith, “Redneck Lady” and The Gray Album, Hotlanta’s “Yeah!” and Metropolis’s “Yeah” — all massive and relatively totally different tales. Us content material suppliers — most of the youthful ones serfs until backed up by faculty loans or mother and father or spouses or precise jobs (virtually definitely underpaid in the event that they’re editorial) — are anticipated to take advantage of the discretionary revenue of the better-compensated younger by enjoying these tales for all they’re value, which means greater than they’re value, within the determined hope that advertisers and so forth. They usually served this perform all too properly. In each case I’ve simply cited, the large tales got here with overrated music.

Not dangerous, often. However overrated — palpably restricted in ambition, achievement, or each. With due respect to the pro-gay posture I pray they stick to — which isn’t required of the fabulous Scissor Sisters, who proved the whole lot they needed to in 15 minutes — Franz Ferdinand are a cautious little band in contrast even to their conceptual forebears the Strokes. Lynn stopped recording her personal songs as a result of “One’s on the Approach” and “When the Tingle Turns into a Chill” have been more true than “Portland Oregon” or, God assist us, “God Makes No Errors.” The as soon as precocious Usher is a cute intercourse object matured into the standard conniving pussy magnet; the completely precocious Banhart is a female-identified weirdo-on-principle whose spontaneity is already a cultivated pose. Morrissey got here again — from the place, precisely? to what, precisely? Elliott Smith launched a posthumous album very very similar to his prehumous albums, which not even the junkies manqué who love him declare had a lot life to them. Gretchen Wilson’s high-trash Tanya Tucker tribute is as painstakingly constructed as Hazard Mouse’s time-seizing ’60s replace, and neither is as convincing because it swears it’s. “Hell yeah!” Gretchen’s sisters refrain on cue. “Yeah!” screams a 20-on-a-scale-of-10 shorty going all up on Usher, conscious with out considering on it that if she don’t Luda will ejaculate her from his Jag. LCD Soundsystem’s lead cyborg sums up the collective dilemma after his girlies intone their very own “Yeah”s: “Everyone retains on speaking about it/No one’s getting it completed.” I simply want he’d added, “Together with me.”

Given the overall longing for affirmation, it’s no marvel our 793 voters ratified artists who embraced their freedom to make music. Frequent finishers Wilco and Björk, Tom Waits and PJ Harvey withdrew deeper into personal aesthetics — the primary pair esoteric and obscurantist, the second spare and formalist. I discovered all 4 missing however most popular the formalists; the citizens cheered all of them on, favoring the obscurantists. Sonic Youth took each routes directly as standard, drawing out and smudging up their catchiest album since Soiled; Nick Cave wrote a couple of songs worthy of the actual Leonard Cohen (not the imposter who got here in 243rd) and stretched them right into a double CD. Newcomers additionally acquired idea factors that divided up mod and trad, with getting it completed left for a greater day. Stay, Akron’s Black Keys extract large blues from a guitar and a lure set, however composing in that fashion is a uncommon knack, so Rubber Manufacturing unit scored on accrued rep and improved distribution. And although Brooklyn’s unkempt TV on the Radio might sometime quantity to greater than 12th place in a critics’ ballot, I want their boosters would admit that they get race factors too. Commonly credited with a funk and soul imperceptible to the unseeing ear, they’re the primary African American rock band of important consequence since Dwelling Color put the Black Rock Coalition into follow 15 years in the past, and whereas Vernon Reid’s Yohimbe Brothers (zero mentions) stream higher, stream doesn’t “rock.”

Cultivating probably the most personal aesthetic of all was the yr’s main underground development. So disdainful of the literal that it’s successfully apolitical even when it needs in any other case, the artier-than-thou traditionalism of psych-folk is a hippie revival rooted in acoustic eccentrics I’d hoped have been behind me three many years in the past, from the Unimaginable String Band and Tim Buckley right down to Essra Mohawk and I see the place one website is hawking Kay Huntington, whose atrocious album should be in my space for storing (yours for $200 to the privatized progressives of my selection, folkies — how concerning the American Negro School Fund?). Psych-folk enrages a few of my youthful colleagues, however I’m too previous to really feel threatened — Devendra Banhart’s expertise is quirkier and fewer pretentious than Buckley’s (not simply Tim’s, Jeff’s), and the poetic acrobatics and pure brainpower of the equally arch Joanna Newsom simply go to point out that in these fragmented occasions any scene can generate a visionary.

These paired hereditary bohemians symbolize psych-folk uncut, however different finishers are shut allies, as are 52nd-place Christian Sufjan Stevens, a lot prettier and deeper than 48th-place ex-Christian Sam Bean. (41–50: electronica standard-bearers Junior Boys, electronica salesmen Air, tape-eating Walkmen, Alicia “Legs” Keys, tweaker-folk Mountain Goats, get together woman Gretchen Wilson, new wave popsters Futureheads, d/b/a Iron & Wine, new wave art-rockers Secret Machines, prescription-only Ted Leo.) Although the Fiery Furnaces determine rock, their roots riffs, opaque verbiage, and kooky air cross-market them as successfully as in the event that they’d deliberate it. The vaguely tribal Animal Collective muster extra allure if much less talent than the Unimaginable String Band. And Nellie McKay has nothing to do with the development in any respect — besides that she’s a trad-avant acoustic singer-songwriter who’s vegetarian too. It’s sufficient to persuade you that fame-averse obscurantism is psych-folk’s important ingredient.

Or perhaps to point that, a couple of separatists however, this wasn’t a lot of a yr for disengagement. McKay’s starvation for a public presence counts as defiance in a state bent on repression. In fact alt-rock made a displaying. A.C. Newman’s solo report outran Neko Case’s solo report; the Libertines took their falling-apart-in-front-of-your-eyes act up to now that Pete Doherty withdrew from view, a complicated impact. The Arcade Hearth are neither hype nor fluke, and although they might select art-rock vainglory, they might additionally show world leaders. However solely Craig Finn’s Maintain Regular went alt all the best way — Virtually Killed Me might move for an idea album concerning the circuit, and though Finn’s storytelling has misplaced a number of twists since Lifter Puller, I want his Pushcart Prize bid properly until John Darnielle enters the Mountain Goats. However he positive didn’t write higher than the Drive-By Truckers, who put out a barely subpar album in half the time it will have taken most bands to write down half the fabric and toured like they have been the Allman Brothers, or than Rilo Kiley, who secured major-label distribution for an album keyed to catchier songs than “Take You Out” if not “Anyone Advised Me.” After which there have been the Blairniks of Interpol, who started their album with a hopeful “We ain’t going to the city/We’re going to the town,” solely to reveal why exurbanites flee the town and vote Republican to maintain it away from their doorways. “See the dwelling that surrounds me/Dissipate in a violent race,” their charting “Sluggish Palms” goes. Precisely what the exurbs are afraid of. Metropolis individuals dance to that? Sick, simply sick.

However, throughout a theoretical pop/semipop realm I’ll dub the Republic of Crunk Guitar, metropolis individuals have been dancing. Crunk guitar is theoretical not least as a result of the guitars that shade the sexist celebration hip-hop signified by the soon-passé “crunk” are soiled and metallic whereas the guitars (and synthesizers) that propelled younger rockers onto the ground in shocking numbers are clear and digital. The conflation merely insists that, regardless of how loudly and justifiably their adherents and adversaries bitch and moan, for fairly some time the putatively opposed worlds of hip-hop and alt/indie-rock have each been good to us. They’re typically escapist and that makes me bitch and moan. However I always remember, or remorse, that human beings have all the time treasured music for the escape it affords.

In 2004, hip-hop, persistently underrepresented in our ballot and by now declared lifeless as frequently as rock, however produced a second straight No. 1 album. Although the voters got here out stronger for OutKast, I’ll take Kanye’s assured pop-soul hooks, modest movement, saving cameos, group-focused imaginative and prescient, and dynamite humorousness; hip to trendy serfdom and too respectable to hawk thug domination fantasies, he renders nerdiness directly cute and racially credible whereas mocking the lie that it’ll get the oppressed what they deserve. A pointy dip in r&b social gathering anthems on our singles chart means that as hip-hop’s business dominance will get previous, its crassness appears worse. However we nonetheless signed off on a wholesome complement of main and indie hip-hop albums. I price Nas (59th) and the slept-on Mos Def (77th) over the belatedly beloved Ghostface, and along with the three worthy albums launched by this yr’s indie-rap fave, MF Doom (whose Madlib collab Madvillainy was No. 11), advocate the Bay Space’s arch-in-his-disgusting-way Z Man and Vancouver’s sincere-in-his-businesslike-way McEnroe. In London, Mike Skinner’s lit rode vocal dramatics that recalled with out resembling the declamations of Ghostface and Chuck D, and Dizzee Rascal’s up-and-at-’em made music of the scrawny techno-dancehall by-product that’s grime. I additionally loved ex-Detroiter Eminem, who was edged out by the competing white beatmasters of NYC’s DFA.

Besotted with Franz Ferdinand’s No. 1 single, some may argue that r&b celebration music was undercut by DOR — dance-oriented rock, youngsters, so abbreviated properly earlier than Duran Duran glitzed their method into your impressionable sensoriums. However the singles chart reveals dance music from every-which-where, with DOR only one element: the Killers’ overtly mechanical “Any person Informed Me,” the Scissor Sisters for the second and Gwen Stefani endlessly, some rely “Float On,” and allow us to not overlook these Blairniks. Moderately than danceability, what distinguishes our rock albums is chart clout. In fact Pazz & Joppers all the time like bands that promote somewhat, and right here’s hoping if not predicting that they’ll all the time have Maintain Steadys to get scorching for. Rock radio continues to die, too. However the Franz Ferdinand–Inexperienced Day–Modest Mouse trifecta constitutes an uptick. Teenpop having given approach to American idolization, which may also run its course, the surviving megalabels are pursuing saner long-term musical funding methods on a enjoying subject the place indies are entrenched, costs have fallen, and downloading is a progressive drive. If the world wasn’t coming to an finish, this may equal cause to be cheerful.

Admittedly, it makes me really feel just a little higher anyway. However there’s solely so pleased you will get concerning the Killers. So permit me to advertise extra far-ranging escapes — beginning with, of all issues, a longshot nation finisher. Huge & Wealthy are a bit moist for my tastes; although they usefully exemplify the kinds of Christian expertise, that Jesus music is simply too corny. However their irreverence and urge for food are such a aid in a Nashville that’s gynephobic and xenophobic when it’s rowdy in any respect. Gretchen Wilson is fortunate to have met them, and never solely that — you simply know they’d respect Piracy Funds Terrorism, the 23rd-place bootleg combine Floridian-Philadelphian Diplo imposed on the forthcoming album by Sri Lankan–British singer-toaster M.I.A. M.I.A.’s eighth-place bhangra-dancehall-grime “Galang” is just probably the most explicitly every-which-where of dance singles that embrace crunk lite from a peripatetic Military brat, ragga lite from Queens-based Puerto Rican–I-think twins, trash lite from queens doing their Elton John impression, blues-rap that includes an avant-garde trumpeter doing his Muddy Waters impression, fragile Norwegian-blond Europop, Blairniks, and DFA. Eclecticism/internationalism has lengthy been dance music’s means, nevertheless it intensified in 2004, and I belief its timing will maintain getting higher with out additional encouragement or explication from me.

Typically, nevertheless, explication deepens enjoyment in addition to enlarging the thoughts. I’d love the Diplo boot extra if it raided the Center in addition to the Far East, the best way Hispanic/multiracial hip-hoppers and 1998 Pazz & Jop finishers Ozomatli did to jump-start their mysteriously-or-maybe-not 208th-place Road Indicators. That’s why I used to be so happy that Youssou N’Dour’s Egypt completed 34th. All the time Islamic, N’Dour is aware of he’s heard as merely African by the People and Europeans whose musics he’s assimilated. In order a political act, the Senegalese Mouridist claimed Muslim by recording in Cairo. This uncommonly pointed one-worldism sinks deeper whenever you learn not simply the notes however the linked information on the Nonesuch web site. Probably the most beautiful album of N’Dour’s profession celebrates an Islamic tradition extra humane than any fundamentalist one, or than the secular compromises putative liberals like Thomas Friedman pump. It’s extra humane than Nashville’s tradition, too — and, typically, NYC’s.

Partially, I do know, my pessimism about America displays my age. At 62, I had my expectations primed again when the objective of a humane society was axiomatic, and at 62, I deeply resent the prospect of spending my golden years battling goons who hate every part I’ve lived for. So it’s salutory to replay The School Dropout — a report I as soon as foolishly feared would put on skinny — and listen to Kanye’s kiddies wickedly refrain, “We wasn’t imagined to make it previous 25/Joke’s on you we nonetheless alive.” That’s the way it goes with social disasters. They worsen than the crack epidemic, however not so’s the top of the world is definitely the top of the world — not even after a suitcase nuke, or the worst-case penalties of dumping the Kyoto accords. All yr I remembered Ned Sublette’s Cuba and Its Music, the place slaves jamming their stinking barracones after which blacks crowding their overtaxed barrios musick defiantly anyway. Protecting it actual f’actual, West’s songs import that impulse into trendy African American life — music is a dream that waxes and wanes, one thing people will steal as a result of it’s one thing people reside for. His good cheer assumes his individuals will get squeezed half to dying, and gained’t cease gained’t cease anyway. Politically, he exhibits extra smarts and higher instincts than any finisher besides N’Dour and the Drive-By Truckers.

Brian Wilson’s good cheer proceeded from a deeper sense of entitlement but proved deeply fragile — he broke down nicely earlier than the ’60s did. However the luck of profession improvement impelled him to re-examine his personal flowering, and although my aversion to ’60s nostalgia is aware of no bounds, his political timing couldn’t have been higher. Nostalgia is for the weak-minded, however historical past is forgotten by those that discover out too late why Karl Rove name-checks William McKinley. Smiley Smile was all the time fantastic, and psych-folkies might need to know that it’s extra eccentric than SMiLE. However SMiLE is a historical past lesson, one which’s solely rendered extra vivid and persuasive by how foolish it’s, and in addition by how worn Wilson’s voice is. The sweetness it achieves regardless — the apotheosis of the Seashore Boys’ trick of respecting and undermining their music classes concurrently — defines the cultural area the place the liberty to make and listen to valuable music was and stays unquestioned if not uncompromised. As in all artistic endeavors, that area is a fiction, or anyway a development. Nevertheless it’s value battling for.

Prime 10 Albums of 2004

1. Kanye West: The School Dropout (Roc-A-Fella)

2. Brian Wilson: SMiLE (Nonesuch)

three. Loretta Lynn: Van Lear Rose (Interscope)

four. Franz Ferdinand: Franz Ferdinand (Domino/Epic)

5. Inexperienced Day: American Fool (Reprise)

6. The Arcade Hearth: Funeral (Merge)

7. The Streets: A Grand Don’t Come for Free (Vice/Atlantic)

eight. U2: The way to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb (Interscope)

9. Modest Mouse: Good Information for Individuals Who Love Dangerous Information (Epic)

10. Hazard Mouse: The Gray Album (

Prime 10 Singles of 2004

1. Franz Ferdinand: “Take Me Out” (Domino)

2. Jay-Z: “99 Issues” (Roc-A-Fella)

three. Usher that includes Lil Jon and Ludacris: “Yeah!” (Arista)

four. Modest Mouse: “Float On” (Epic)

5. Britney Spears: “Poisonous” (Jive)

6. Kanye West: “Jesus Walks” (Roc-A-Fella)

7. Snoop Dogg that includes Pharrell: “Drop It Like It’s Scorching” (Doggystyle/Geffen/Star Trak)

eight. M.I.A.: “Galang” (XL)

9. Yeah Yeah Yeahs: “Maps” (Interscope)

10. U2: “Vertigo” (Interscope)

—From the February 9–15, 2005, situation


Pazz & Jop essays and outcomes may also be discovered on Robert Christgau’s website. His most up-to-date e-book, Is It Nonetheless Good to Ya? Fifty Years of Rock Criticism, 1967–2017, was revealed final yr.

(perform(d, s, id)
var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];
if (d.getElementById(id)) return;
js = d.createElement(s); = id;
js.src = “//join.fb.internet/en_US/all.js#xfbml=1”;
fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs);

(doc, ‘script’, ‘facebook-jssdk’));